Numeric nutrient criteria last week, judge hinkle signed orders granting motions filed by the environmental protection agency epa and the florida department of environmental protection dep regarding the enforcement of numeric nutrient criteria in florida. Definitions, numeric interpretations of narrative nutrient criteria, estuaryspecific numeric interpretations of the narrative nutrient criterion, site specific alternative criteria. Some florida lakes failing the new numeric nutrient criteria. Chlorophylla is a response variable that measures biotic productivity and activity, thus reflecting the nutrient enrichment of the system. Greater detail on species life history and status are available in the recovery plans and status reports for. An approach to develop numeric nutrient criteria for georgia and. Grubbs memo 2001 memorandum to provide additional guidance to states and authorized tribes on developing nutrient criteria plans, the role of these plans in the adoption of nutrient criteria, the flexibility available, and epas expectations for the timeframes both to develop a plan and to adopt nutrient criteria into water quality standards. Scientific and technical basis of the numeric nutrient criteria for. Numeric nutrient standards are provided in florida administrative code fac and are available on the fdep website. State adoption of numeric nutrient standards 1998 2008 2 u. Biological opinion on epa approval of fl water quality standards.
A synopsis of research completed for the us environmental protection agency james d. Numeric nutrient criteria on tuesday, the united states district court for the northern district of florida heard oral arguments on the cross motions of epa and earthjustice et al. Scientific and technical basis of the numeric nutrient. The site features maps and tables showing development of nitrogen and phosphorus criteria from 2016 projected through 2019. In 2009 epa determined that numeric, rather than narrative, nutrient criteria. Empirical approaches to establishing numeric nutrient. These efforts are a result of legal action brought against epa by earthjustice in 2008. Oct 09, 20 stories about numeric nutrient criteria from growing produce. In addition, the department has modified somewhat the process by which numeric criteria are derived. This paper will discuss the history and impacts of the epas numeric nutrient criteria nnc and the recently approved florida department of environmental protection fdep regulations. Science supporting numeric nutrient criteria for lakes and.
Numeric nutrient criteria in the state of florida status and meaning of november 30, 2012 action by epa summary. Environmental protection agency epa approved state standards for the prevention of nutrient pollution in floridas waterways. Nutrient criteria for water quality missouri department of. Therefore, for streams in florida, the applicable nutrient water quality standard for cwa purposes remains the narrative criteria. Numeric nutrient criteria development plan march 2009. On march 3, 2009 dep submitted its current numeric nutrient criteria development plan to epa region iv. Dietary dri reference intakes national agricultural library.
Missouris numeric nutrient criteria nnc for lakes at 10 csr 207. Chlorophylla concentrations are a direct response to causal variables total nitrogen and total phosphorus. Fdep implemented a detailed, usepaapproved plan for the development of numeric nutrient criteria and proposed revisions to chapter 62302, f. Numeric nutrient criteria for the state of florida. Environmental protection agencys epa approach to addressing the challenge of managing nutrient pollution has included supporting development of numeric nutrient criteria for the nations waters.
Numeric nutrient criteria implementation workshop featured panelists drew bartlet deputy secretary of water policy and ecosystem restoration department of environmental protection andrew bartlett is the deputy secretary of water policy and ecosystem restoration. The welldocumented adverse effects of nitrogen and phosphorus pollution include harmful algal blooms, reduced spawning grounds and nursery habitats, fish kills, oxygenstarved hypoxic or dead zones where fish and aquatic life can no longer survive, and public health concerns related to. Water quality standards including nnc help to protect and restore the quality of the nations surface waters, consistent with the requirements of the clean water act cwa. While fdeps nutrient rule is not yet effective for state law purposes, epa believes that fdeps numeric nutrient criteria represent fdeps most recent interpretation of paragraph 62302. Pdf on january 26, 2010, the united state environmental protection agency usepa published proposed numeric nutrient criteria for flowing waters of. Economic analysis of the proposed federal numeric nutrient. Wyomings surface water quality standards currently only include narrative criteria to protect designated uses from nutrient pollution. State of florida numeric nutrient criteria development plan march 2009 vii figure b3. In 2009, the department initiated rulemaking and, by 2011, adopted what would be the first set of statewide numeric nutrient standards for floridas waters. Implementation of floridas numeric nutrient standards. State progress toward developing numeric nutrient water quality criteria for nitrogen and phosphorus epa has developed an interactive website to show state progress on developing numeric nutrient criteria.
State adoption of numeric nutrient standards 19982008. Examination of the historical record or paleoecological evidence for. Numeric nutrient criteria established for tidal creeks must consider the different ecological processes and functions that distinguish them from both the freshwater systems upstream and the open estuary downstream. See technical support for numeric nutrient criteria development. Environmental protection agency epa was sued by floridas wildlife federation fwf over the lack of nnc in florida. Numeric nutrient criteria are established for all estuary segments, including criteria for total nitrogen, total phosphorus, and chlorophyll a. Impaired waters rule iwr to establish numeric nutrient criteria for lakes and streams. Pdf an approach to develop numeric nutrient criteria for georgia. State of florida numeric nutrient criteria development plan.
Six basins have been previously define in soflo, namely biscayne bay bb. Nutrient criteria for montanas wadeable streams and. Nutrient pollution remains one of the most prevalent causes of water quality impairment in the united states. Pdf an approach to develop numeric nutrient criteria for. Some florida lakes failing the new numeric nutrient criteria florida lakewatch school of forest resources and conservation institute of food and agricultural sciences university of florida the united stated environmental protection agency has set limits on the concentrations of total nitrogen tn, total phosphorus tp and algal chlorophyll a. Rationale for missouri numeric nutrient criteria for lakes. About floridas numeric nutrient standards for lakes and. Stories about numeric nutrient criteria from growing produce. Approves these rules in their entirety, concludes rulemaking that removes federal numeric nutrient criteriain response to the approval, and. Numeric nutrient standards for florida watersbackgroundfor many decades florida has had a narrative nutrient water quality criterion in place to protect. Please find enclosed a petition from the florida department of environmental protection requesting that the u. About floridas numeric nutrient standards for lakes and rivers the change from qualitative assessment to numeric nutrient standards for floridas inland lakes and rivers will necessitate many changes in the way water resource managers perform monitoring and mitigation activities. Overview usepas take on the combined criteria bioconfirmation approach transparency in determining condition status based on approach box models as decision trees the michigan example the only really novel material presented at the meeting.
Numeric nutrient criteria in florida an overview march 23, 2012 page 2 however, on january 14, 2009, epa formally determined that numeric nutrient criteria should be established on an expedited schedule. Numeric nutrient criteria deq wyoming department of. To create scientific information that could assist the agency and its. Hagy iii us epa nheerl gulf ecology division gulf breeze, fl epa science advisory board december 14, 2010 washington, d. Box plot comparison of sci scores and ldi values calculated based on a 100 m. Numeric nutrient criteria numeric criteria for total nitrogen and total phosphorus and response parameters e. The magnitude component is the longterm limit ltl estimated from a single segment or group of. Numeric nutrient criteria florida association of counties.
Incorporated into discharge permits used to assess waters for impairment used to develop total maximum daily loads. Numeric nutrient criteria in the status and meaning of. Epa600r15262 science supporting numeric nutrient criteria for lakes and their watersheds. For open ocean coastal waters, numeric criteria are established for chlorophyll a that are derived from satellite remote sensing techniques. Environmental protection agency office of research and development national health and environmental effects research laboratory, gulf ecology division u. The science of eutrophication in general and numeric nutrient criteria in particular has continued to advance in the interim years. Agricultural and industry groups, who intervened in that lawsuit, have pending. Rather than litigate the issue, in january 2009 epa made this determination relating to. Georgias plan for the adoption of water quality standards.
When an essential nutrient is needed for the organism to complete its life history and it is not. State progress toward developing numeric nutrient water. The epas 1976 publication entitled quality criteria for water also known as the red book contains. Estuaryspecific numeric interpretations of the narrative nutrient criterion. Under florida law, email addresses are public records.
In 2009, epa made a determination, under section 303c4b of the clean water act, that the narrative. The intent of numeric nutrient criteria is to assure a level of water quality that will protect the beneficial uses of these waterbodies. Major lakes monitoring program lakes currently without numeric nutrient criteria 2. It is fdeps intent to establish numeric nutrient criteria that are protectiveof designated uses and consistent with floridas existing narrative nutrient criterion, which states that in no case. For all other bay segments, the criteria shall not be exceeded in more than 10 percent of the measurements. Development of numeric nutrient criteria under the clean water act helps to. Deq has developed numeric water quality criteria intended to control excessive nutrient nitrogen and phosphorus pollution in montanas streams, rivers, and lakes. Withdrawing the federal actions factsheet keywords. Site specific alternative criteria ssac for one or more nutrients or nutrient response variables as established under rule 62302. Georgias plan for the adoption of water quality standards for nutrients july 20 revision 2. Numeric nutrient standards for the state of florida. This paper will provide a regulatory update on the nnc for all waterbodies and how. Criteria for streams, lakes, springs, open coastal, and part 3 and 4 estuaries are not currently in effect remaining nnc become effective only if epa.
Following that formal determination, epa entered into a consent decree with the environmental groups, establishing a schedule for the adoption of numeric nutrient criteria. State adoption of numeric nutrient standards 1998 2008 sometimes hundreds of miles away. The state of numeric nutrient criteria in the state of. Division of environmental assessment and restoration florida department of environmental protection tallahassee, fl. Florida is the first state where nnc are being fully implemented, the results of which could set precedence for other states. Proposed methodology for the assessment of protective numeric. The first numeric nutrient criteria nnc for lakes and reservoirs were adopted as part of the water quality standards rule in october 2009. According to the epa, to an unknown degree, variances from strict compliance with the criteria may be granted for specific water bodies.
Protection fdep are developing numeric nutrient criteria for south florida estuaries and coastal waters. The department allows for an acceptable range of annual geometric. Numeric nutrient criteria, concentrations of nitrogen andor phosphorus and response variables such as chlorophyll a, are expected to more effectively protect wyomings surface waters because they can be used to more consistently. The currently applicable water quality standards for all nnc in missouri are located at 10 csr 207. Developing numeric nutrient criteria for freshwaters mississippi. Proposed methodology for the assessment of protective. Environmental protection agency epa approved state standards for the prevention of nutrient pollution in floridas waterways applicable to 100% of floridas rivers, streams, lakes and to estuaries. Numeric nutrient criteria development for florida estuaries presented by.
Considerations for lake water quality criteria development this chapter provides a general discussion of the criteriasetting process and the variables that. Epa has long recognized that numeric nutrient criteria are needed to control. Numeric nutrient standards for florida watersbackgroundfor many decades florida has had a narrative nutrient water quality criterion in place to protect floridas waters against nutrient overenrichment. Agricultural and industry groups, who intervened in. About floridas numeric nutrient standards for lakes and rivers. Evolution of water quality regulations in the united states and florida. It is important that the established criteria for tidal creeks also account. An approach to develop numeric nutrient criteria for georgia and south carolina estuaries technical report pdf available february 2016 with 118 reads how we measure reads. Numeric nutrient criteria development florida department. Section 303c of the act authorizes epa to set federal criteria where determines it is necessary to meet the requirements of this act. For lakes, the applicable numeric interpretations of the nnc in paragraph 62302.
Florida numeric nutrient criteria 2012 update surface. Established chlorophyll a, tn and tp criteria started with target chlorophyll a, and then set tn and tp criteria based on statistical relationship between nutrients and chl a criteria vary depending on color and alkalinity expressed as annual geometric means that cannot be exceeded more than once in a threeyear period. Epa is withdrawing federal water quality standards wqs applicable to waters of the state of florida now that florida has adopted and epa has approved relevant numeric. Summary of region 5 numeric nutrient criteria workshop. Nutrient and nutrient response values do not apply to tidally. For decades florida has experienced its share of nutrient related pollution issues. Status of numeric nutrient criteria development author. Numeric nutrient criteria development florida department of. Numeric nutrient criteria in florida 6 comprehensive stateadopted nnc upon fulfillment of the agreement in principle and path forward, florida will have stateestablished numeric nutrient criteria for all lakes, springs, estuaries and coastal waters, and the vast majority of flowing waters. Numeric nutrient criteria for the panhandle estuaries. Approval of florida numeric nutrient criteria for total. Usgs historical continuous wq including do in ga and sc. Nov, 2012 k perdido bay for bay segments with criteria expressed as annual geometric means agm, the values shall not be exceeded more than once in a three year period.
1041 901 1076 348 481 975 591 1532 79 1064 982 402 1195 636 685 437 1360 313 1397 1511 361 446 1455 1212 698 890 947 729 1417 249 772 54 887 857 913